Can I Disagree With My Editor? Understanding the Author-Editor Relationship

The publishing process requires more than just an author’s creativity and hard work. It also involves feedback, critique, and editing. This leaves many writers asking, “Can I disagree with an editor?”

Once you take the leap from solitary writing to the publishing world, whether you’re pursuing independent or traditional publication, it becomes a team effort. A good editor is crucial to the development of your work and career. But what happens if you disagree with your editor’s suggestions?

In this article, we’ll explore the editor-author relationship, the reasons behind disagreements, and how to navigate them while still maintaining a positive and productive collaboration.

For the purposes of this post, we’re talking about the relationship between authors and hired editors. The relationship with the editors at your publishing house may be different.

What is an Editor’s Role in the Writing Process?

An editor’s job is to review, strengthen, and polish a manuscript. Depending on the type of editor, that may include providing feedback on the story or making direct edits to the prose. Read this post for a breakdown of the different types of editing.

Developmental editors recommend changes for strengthening the plot, enhancing characters, and improving pacing. Line editors make changes for clarity, consistency, and concision. Ultimately, an editor’s goal is to make the author’s work shine and appeal to readers.

A good editor works in the best interest of both the manuscript and the author’s career.

Why Do Disagreements Arise Between Authors and Editors?

While both editors and authors have the same end goal—to produce a successful book and support the author’s career—they may have different ideas on how to get there. Editors may suggest changes that authors feel go against their vision or voice. Authors may feel that their work is being changed too much and losing its originality or uniqueness. Disagreements can also arise due to a lack of communication, a misunderstanding, or personal differences.

Can I Disagree with My Editor?

Yes, you can. Disagreements are a natural part of any creative collaboration. However, it’s important to approach the situation professionally and respectfully. Start by expressing your concerns and asking questions about the editor’s suggestions. The first step is to ensure you fully understand what the editor is suggesting and why.

Remember to keep an open mind. After all, you’re paying for the editor’s expertise. Ultimately, the final decision is up to the author, so there is no reason to get upset about feedback with which you disagree.

Reasons for Disagreements Between Authors and Editors

There are several reasons why disagreements may arise between authors and editors. Here are some common ones:

• Differences in Style or Vision: As we discussed earlier, authors and editors may have different ideas about the style and vision of a particular piece of writing. This can lead to disagreements about everything from word choice to plot structure. Discussing the project and your goals before beginning work can help prevent this.
• Miscommunication: Sometimes, disagreements between authors and editors can arise simply due to miscommunication. For example, an editor may make changes that the author doesn’t understand or agree with, but the editor may not have explained their reasoning clearly.
• Ego: Sometimes, disagreements can arise due to egos on both sides. The author may feel that the editor is trying to change their work too much, while the editor may feel that the author is too attached to their own writing and not open to feedback.
• Lack of Trust: Disagreements may arise due to a lack of trust between the author and editor. If the author feels that the editor doesn’t understand their work or isn’t respecting their vision, they may be more resistant to making changes.

By understanding these common reasons for disagreements, authors and editors can work together to find solutions that benefit both the story and the author’s career. Effective communication, mutual respect, and a willingness to ask questions can go a long way in fostering a strong author-editor relationship.

How to Handle Disagreements with Your Editor

Here are some tips for handling disagreements with your editor:

• Clarify Expectations: Make sure you and your editor are on the same page regarding the goals and vision for your manuscript. Ask questions, provide examples, and communicate clearly. At Blue Pen, we ask authors to fill out a brief about their work and goals before we begin editing for this very reason.

• Be Specific: When providing feedback or expressing concerns, be specific and give concrete examples. Vague or general complaints can lead to misunderstandings.
• Ask Questions: Make sure you understand exactly what your editor is suggesting and why. If you are unsure about their reasoning, ask for clarification.
• Check Your Ego: While you are in no way obligated to take all of your editor’s advice, make sure you’re not resisting based solely on the hit to your ego. Remember Stephen King’s famous words: “Kill your darlings.”
• Offer Alternatives: If you disagree with your editor’s suggestions, provide alternative solutions that align with your vision and style.
• Be Respectful: Keep a professional and respectful tone when communicating with your editor. Remember that they are there to help you improve your work.
• Compromise: Be willing to compromise and find common ground. Consider your editor’s expertise and experience, but also trust your instincts as an author.

What to Do When You Can’t Agree with Your Editor

In some cases, disagreements may be more challenging to overcome. If you feel that your editor is not respecting your vision or style, it may be time to seek a second opinion or find a new editor. However, it’s important to remember that editing is a collaborative process, and finding the right fit can take time and effort. Before making any rash decisions, try to work through the issues with your editor and keep an open mind.

Consider whether the disagreement is regarding a single point or if it represents a pattern of misaligned visions. If the disagreement is about one specific issue, you as the author have the final say, and a professional editor will understand and respect that fact.

Fostering a Strong Author-Editor Relationship

Fostering a strong author-editor relationship is crucial for a successful publishing experience. Here are some tips for building a positive and productive relationship with your editor:

• Communicate Openly and Respectfully: Be clear and direct in your communication with your editor. Explain your goals and vision for your work, and listen to their feedback and suggestions with an open mind. Remember that your editor is a professional who wants to help you succeed, so be respectful of their time and expertise.
• Be Responsive and Timely: Respond to your editor’s emails and messages in a timely manner, and discuss your communication preferences with them. This will help ensure that the editing process moves forward smoothly and efficiently.
• Be Willing to Consider Feedback: While it’s important to maintain your unique voice and vision, be willing to consider your editor’s feedback and suggestions. That’s why you’re paying them, after all. Consider taking creative approaches to addressing issues, finding solutions that honor your creative vision.
• Be Open to Feedback and Criticism: Receiving feedback and criticism can be difficult, but it’s an essential part of the writing and editing process. Be open to constructive criticism and use it as an opportunity to improve your work. Remember that criticism is not directed at you as a person, and it doesn’t mean you’re a bad writer. As Ernest Hemingway said, “We are all apprentices in a craft where no one ever becomes a master.”
• Show Gratitude and Appreciation: Remember to thank your editor for their hard work and dedication throughout the editing process. A simple thank-you note or gesture of appreciation can go a long way in building a strong and positive author-editor relationship. If you really benefited from the editing experience, offer to write them a testimonial.

By following these tips, you can build a strong and productive author-editor relationship that will help you create the best possible work and achieve your publishing goals.

How to Choose the Perfect Book Editor

Choosing an editor who you will work well with is crucial to the success of your writing project. Here are some tips for selecting the right editor for you:

1. Look for Experience in Your Genre: Choose an editor who has experience editing the type of writing that you do. If you write fiction, look for an editor who specializes in fiction. If you write nonfiction, look for an editor who specializes in your specific subject matter.
2. Consider Your Budget: Editing services can vary widely in price. Determine your budget beforehand, and look for editors who offer services within your price range. Remember to look for editors whose rates fall within the industry standards noted in the EFA’s survey.
3. Read Reviews and Testimonials: Check out reviews and testimonials from previous clients to get an idea of the editor’s quality of work and professionalism. Check out Blue Pen’s testimonials.
4. Ask for Sample Edits: Many (but not all) editors offer sample edits to potential clients. This will give you a sense of the editor’s style and approach, and help you determine whether they are a good fit for your project. Blue Pen provides sample edits with authors’ permission.
5. Communicate Your Needs and Expectations: When you contact a potential editor, be clear about your needs and expectations. Explain your goals and vision for your work, and ask questions about their editing process and communication style.
6. Trust Your Instincts: Ultimately, it’s important to choose an editor who you feel comfortable working with. Trust your instincts and choose someone who you believe will be a good fit for your project.

By following these tips, you can select the right editor for your work, who will help you create the best possible version of your manuscript.

FAQs

Q: What if my editor is making changes I don’t agree with?

A: Talk to your editor and express your concerns. Make sure you understand exactly what they are suggesting and why, and think about creative ways you can address the underlying issues. Remember that you as the author do have the final say in which changes are made.

Q: What if my editor is not respecting my vision or style?

A: If your editor is not respecting your vision or style, it’s essential to communicate your concerns clearly and respectfully. First of all, make sure they understand your vision. Consider whether the issue represents a pattern or if it is a one-time disagreement. If the problem persists, consider finding a different editor who better aligns with your goals and vision.

Q: How can I maintain my unique voice and vision while working with an editor?

A: Working with an editor doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice your unique voice and vision. A good editor will work with you to enhance and clarify your voice. Be clear about your goals and vision, and communicate openly with your editor to ensure you’re both on the same page.

Q: What should I expect during the editing process?

A: The editing process typically involves several rounds of feedback, including developmental editing, line editing, and proofreading. Developmental editing focuses on the structure and content of your work, while line editing focuses on the language and style. Proofreading is the final stage, during which the editor checks for spelling, grammar, and punctuation errors.

Q: How can I build a strong author-editor relationship?

A: Building a strong author-editor relationship takes time and effort. It’s essential to communicate openly, be respectful of each other’s time and expertise, and maintain a professional attitude. Remember that your editor is your ally, not your adversary, and that your ultimate goal is to create the best possible story—and support your writing career.

Can I Disagree With My Editor and Maintain a Strong Working Relationship?

The relationship between an author and editor can be complex and sometimes challenging, but it is ultimately a partnership that should be based on mutual respect and collaboration. While it can be intimidating to disagree with your editor, it is important to remember that you are the expert on your own writing and vision for your work.

When you do disagree, it is crucial to approach the conversation with professionalism and a willingness to listen and understand the editor’s perspective. By fostering a strong relationship with your editor and selecting the right editor for your project, you can work together to create a final product that both you and your readers will love. Remember to trust your instincts, communicate openly and honestly, and always keep the ultimate goal in mind: to create the best possible version of your work.

If you’re looking for someone with whom you can forge a strong relationship to help strengthen your work, get in touch with our team at Blue Pen.